On data protection, data taxation and data equity: balancing value, risks and obligations
Carregando...
Arquivos
Data
2025
Orientador(res)
Métricas
Título da Revista
ISSN da Revista
Título de Volume
Resumo
This paper critically analyzes the persistent inadequacy of current tax regimes in capturing the economic value of data, despite its frequent characterization as “the new oil,” “a new asset class,” and “the most valuable resource.” Contemporary digital services taxes ( focus mainly on revenues from services built on data processing, such as online advertising and digital intermedia tion, but these measures are largely ineffective and limited in scope. A significant concern is that the extraction and exploitation of vast data volumes from global majority countries by multinational technology corporations remain untaxed, even though su ch data especially high quality local datasets used for AI training generate substantial value. This creates a large untaxed intangible asset class, undermining fair taxation and fiscal sovereignty. Moreover, innovations derived from data processing, often protected by intellectual property rights domiciled in low tax jurisdictions, escape appropriate taxation. The paper argues that tax authorities currently fail to tax both the raw data and the innovations it enables, focusing instead on limited end user d igital services, which contradicts fundamental principles of nexus and value creation in international tax law and facilitates base erosion and profit shifting. Additionally, current tax frameworks do not incentivize compliance with national data protectio n and information security laws, allowing large data intensive firms to externalize social and regulatory costs while benefiting from a triple tax exemption. The paper concludes by calling for comprehensive reforms that recognize data as a taxable intangib le asset and align taxation with the economic value and social costs of data extraction, emphasizing progressive measures targeting the largest data consolidators to ensure data equity and uphold tax system integrity. Lastly, the paper distills the ideas d ebated into a “Proposal for a Framework to Tax Data as an Intangible Asset for Large Extractive Tech Companies.”
